Jonathan Ernst/Reuters The ESG conspiracy is spreading, according to a report this week by Republicans in the House of Representatives. In the report, the House Judiciary Committee accused Wall Street of orchestrating a wide-ranging “climate cartel” with the eventual goal of “the ‘decarbonization’ of American industry,” including everyone from activist groups and California’s public pension to BlackRock and the advisory firm Glass Lewis. The efforts of Vanguard, State Street, and other top asset managers named in the report to downplay their links to the ESG investing movement, including by walking out of the main group targeted in the report, is apparently not enough to take them out of lawmakers’ sights. One curious thing about this cartel is that it apparently isn’t very effective: Once again this year, most climate-related shareholder resolutions at banks and other companies failed to pass. Still, to the extent that there is a shift toward climate consciousness at large asset managers, there are two more obvious reasons than an activist conspiracy: One, that climate change is a genuine threat to long-term portfolio returns, and two, as my colleague Liz Hoffman pointed out, asset managers’ customers are asking for it. |