• D.C.
  • BXL
  • Lagos
  • Dubai
  • Beijing
  • SG
rotating globe
  • D.C.
  • BXL
  • Lagos
Semafor Logo
  • Dubai
  • Beijing
  • SG


In today’s edition, we look at a startup manufacturing tiny homes, which is now launching a mortgage͏‌  ͏‌  ͏‌  ͏‌  ͏‌  ͏‌ 
 
rotating globe
June 20, 2024
semafor

Business

Business
Sign up for our free newsletters
 
Liz Hoffman
Liz Hoffman

Hi, and welcome back to Semafor Business.

Last week, Ben Smith and I met with a startup hawking tiny backyard homes as a fix for the nation’s housing crunch. While Ben, ever keyed into election-year zeitgeist, honed in on the toxic politics around housing, my mind went to just how much fun Wall Street could have with this. Offer a loan that takes equity out of the main house, use it as a down payment for the backyard bungalow, and sell the whole thing to Apollo, I suggested.

So I was delighted when the company, Samara, reached out on Tuesday with just such a product.

Whether backyard dwellings will make a meaningful dent in the housing shortage depends on how people use them. The company sees space for aging parents and rootless kids, or rental units that can help ease shortages and provide extra income. Samara’s aesthetic — airy, with clean lines and cathedral ceilings — seems made for Airbnb, which provided a chunk of its startup funding. And wealthy California families using tiny homes for nannies or private chefs will do little to improve the political climate.

But Wall Street will love this. The financialization of everything — the impulse to turn basic commerce into “income streams” and divert them to ever-more-specialized investment reservoirs — is one of the big economic stories of the century. Sometimes it works great, like when airport shopping malls help pay for new runways. Sometimes we get the subprime mortgage crash.

Plus, in Juneteenth week, a look at why the racial wealth gap hasn’t budged — and one big idea to fix it.

Buy/Sell

PepsiCo Beverages North America

➚ BUY: Nostalgia. Limited Too, a fixture of early-2000s malls, is relaunching this summer. Doc Martens, cargo pants, Pepsi’s new, old logo, and endless Hollywood reboots are luring new shoppers by harkening back.

➘ SELL: Sentiment. Consumer confidence fell for the third straight month in June as Americans’ view of their own finances dimmed.

PostEmail
The Tape

Bank of England signals it may be ready to cut… Hack shuts down car dealerships… S&P 500 rally stalls... Euro politics killed the Golden Goose IPO… Texas investor may bid for soccer team with communist past... Michael Cera skin cream ad takes gold at Cannes…

PostEmail
Liz Hoffman

Can tiny-home mortgages fix California’s housing crisis?

THE SCOOP

A startup that spun out of Airbnb to manufacture tiny homes at a factory in Mexico is launching a mortgage product it hopes will relieve California’s housing crisis.

Samara, which raised $41 million in 2023, is now getting into the financing business. It will start offering a mortgage that lets homeowners take equity out of their primary house to install backyard units, technically called accessory dwelling units, or ADUs.

The company is providing a financing and logistics shortcut for what is perhaps the central policy challenge facing both political parties: A housing crisis that is concentrated in cities like San Francisco and New York but driving unhappiness around the country.

It’s taking advantage of the momentum of the “Yes in My Backyard” (YIMBY) movement, which last year won a change to California law overruling bans on infill. Along with a good financing deal, it could — if widely adopted — offer a way to increase density in some neighborhoods, whether neighbors and local politicians like it or not.

“This is literally people saying, yes, I want this, in my backyard,” said Samara’s CEO, Mike McNamara, who launched the company alongside Airbnb co-founder Joe Gebbia. “The politics around this debate have shifted.”

It’s not just housing policy at Samara’s back. The company is seizing on two financial trends: Rising prices that have left homeowners sitting on a gold mine of equity in their houses, and Wall Street’s insatiable appetite for newfangled loans.

The average homeowner has $300,000 of equity in their house, up from $182,000 before the pandemic, according to CoreLogic. Samara’s offering mimics a second mortgage, but is cheaper, with rates starting around 6.5%. And because about half of its customers already use their ADUs as a rental, there’s an income stream that investors can underwrite.

Samara declined to name its financing partners. CFO Chris Wasley said it will work with banks, investment funds, and securitization channels. (Financing mortgages on its own balance sheet would be a strange use of very expensive venture money.)

Applications for ADUs in California, one of the nation’s most strapped housing markets and the epicenter of the grimy politics associated with it, have risen 20-fold since 2016. States including Colorado, Maine, New Jersey, and Vermont have all taken up or passed laws that would change zoning laws to make it easier to build backyard dwellings. Last week, San Jose became the first city to let owners turn their ADUs into condos and sell them separately.

As the largest generation in US history retires without enough health aides and assisted living facilities to care for them, more parents are moving in with their kids. And the housing crunch means more young adults are living with their parents. Nearly 40% of men between the ages of 25 and 29 were living with an older relative in 2021, according to Pew Research.

Samara sees that trend as key to its fortunes. Customers can use ADUs to “house the grandparents or the kids that come home from school,” McNamara said, “or as a work-from-home office.”

LIZ’S VIEW

We wrote last week about the seemingly endless list of things being securitized right now, spliced and diced and sold into a waiting sea of money at investment funds. Recent weeks have seen novel bonds backed by home heat pumps, Subway franchises, IP addresses, and Sotheby’s art loans. It’s all “a bit spicy,” even for Janus Henderson’s head of securitized product.

“Clearly this should be an asset class,” Wasley, Samara’s CFO, told me, using the language of this massive post-2008 shift in how seemingly everything is being paid for these days. Samara’s loans “should trade below second mortgages and slightly above first mortgages” in terms of investor returns, putting it in a sweet spot for Wall Street investors.

Samara

The impulse for companies to turn their physical products into financial ones is powerful. Rooftop solar companies figured this out years ago. (Wasley spent six years at SolarCity, lining up financing for its customers.) See this chart on auto loans. Online shoppers spend more when they can buy now and pay later, so we now have a thriving BNPL asset class, in which PayPal sells checkout loans to KKR. Lots of rich people like sports, so there is a thriving trade in team stakes.

In theory, plentiful financing should make purchases cheaper, as it did for rooftop solar. But lubricating big purchases — Samara’s two-bed-two-bath model starts at $400,000 — through financial engineering can end badly. It can gull people into taking on debt they don’t understand and can’t repay, as we saw with the government’s green-energy PACE loans.

Homes tend to appreciate in value, unlike solar panels whose technology becomes obsolete, or cars whose value starts declining the minute it’s driven off the lot. Whether the same will be true for tiny homes is less clear to me, but Wall Street firms will be all over this. Some will regret not having thought of it themselves.

PostEmail
Evidence

The racial job gap in the US has nearly closed, but the wage and wealth gaps haven’t.

Employment-population rates, a broader-brush measure that complements the unemployment rate for economists, for white and Black Americans have converged sharply over the past 15 years. Disproportionate job losses among Black workers during the pandemic reversed sharply.

But Black workers earn 21% less than white workers, a gap that hasn’t budged in a quarter-century, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. And their net worth — a better measure of financial security and the key to generational advancement — is about 15% of the average white household. They have 39 cents in retirement accounts for every dollar in white households, and have less “good” debt (primary mortgages) and more “bad” debt (student loans, car loans, installment loans, and second mortgages).

One solution getting an airing these days is an automatic government baby-bond program, which Morningstar says could shrink that wealth gap by two-thirds. Connecticut and Washington, DC both have programs, and several other states are considering measures.

PostEmail
Quotable

“If someone is trying to reach me with an ad, it’s the best place to put an ad.”

— Elon Musk, who tweets 30 times a day, trying to woo advertisers at Cannes back to the platform.

PostEmail
What We’re Tracking

Talent scouts: AI really is everywhere. PayPal, which for years billed itself as one of the tech-savviest companies around, is hiring its new chief technology officer from … Walmart. It’s part of the payments firm’s push into the technology du jour, and credits the work Walmart has done in recent years to catch up to Amazon.

Japan’s SVB: Japan’s premier agricultural bank surprised markets this week by saying it would sell $63 billion of low-yielding US and European government bonds that had become unprofitable as interest rates rose. Sound familiar? That’s the same dynamic that turned US bank balance sheets upside down a year ago and pushed several into failure. Norinchukin’s executives say they simply didn’t expect interest rates in the West to remain this high for this long. The bank projects 1.5 trillion yen ($10 billion) of losses but warned of more based on “market conditions” — whether anyone wants what it’s selling.

PostEmail
Hot on Semafor
  • How Google is reinventing the clean power market.
  • What ‘democracy’ means to the post-Jan. 6 right.
  • Sierra Leone bets on $150 million digital hub strategy.
PostEmail