• D.C.
  • BXL
  • Lagos
  • Dubai
  • Beijing
  • SG
rotating globe
  • D.C.
  • BXL
  • Lagos
Semafor Logo
  • Dubai
  • Beijing
  • SG


In the latest edition, we tackle efforts to grow climate finance for developing countries, and an un͏‌  ͏‌  ͏‌  ͏‌  ͏‌  ͏‌ 
 
sunny Strasbourg
cloudy Nairobi
sunny Caracas
rotating globe
September 27, 2023
semafor

Net Zero

Climate
Sign up for our free newsletters
 
Prashant Rao
Prashant Rao

Hello and welcome back to Net Zero, where we’re still recovering from a whirlwind Climate Week NYC!

Tim is taking a well-deserved vacation, but we’re already busy chasing all the fascinating tips and ideas entrepreneurs, consultants, bankers, and others — including many of you! — gave us last week. One of the big themes of Climate Week was the paucity of finance for developing countries to undertake their own energy transitions. Today, Chloé Farand digs into efforts to address that shortfall: Who’s trying what, and where?

Also this week: A look at how oil majors are upping their output, and where they’re putting their money, as well as a little-noticed reform in China that could hugely accelerate its transition away from fossil fuels.

As always, tell your friends and colleagues about us! It makes a huge difference.

Prashant

Hotspots
  1. A landmark climate lawsuit
  2. The narrow path to 1.5 C
  3. 🟡 Climate finance’s changes
  4. Fossil-fuel funding
  5. 🟡 ‘Style versus substance’
  6. Emissions trading expansion
  7. 🟡 Betting big on Latam
  8. 🟡 China’s power reforms
PostEmail
1

Landmark litigation

Two of the plaintiffs. REUTERS/Pedro Nunes/File Photo

The European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg heard its biggest-ever climate litigation suit today, a case which analysts say could change the way states are held accountable for climate harm. Six Portuguese youths, aged between 11 and 24, are suing 32 governments — all 27 European Union member states plus Norway, Russia, Switzerland, Turkey, and the U.K. — for failing to take adequate climate action, which they argue violates their human rights. They hope to set a precedent for further climate litigation forcing governments to step up their emissions cuts. The case follows successful youth-led legal action in Montana, part of a growing wave of climate litigation worldwide.

PostEmail
2

The (narrow) path

Record investment in clean technologies, including the rapid growth of electric vehicles and solar power, means a narrow path to limiting global heating to 1.5 C remains open, the International Energy Agency said. Other efforts to tackle warming are lagging, however, the IEA warned. Staying on track for a 1.5 C world means almost all countries must bring forward their targeted net-zero dates, clean energy investments must increase to $4.5 trillion a year by the early 2030s from $1.8 trillion in 2023, and fossil fuel demand has to fall by a quarter this decade. “Strong international cooperation is crucial to success. Governments need to separate climate from geopolitics,” said Fatih Birol, the agency’s executive director.

PostEmail
3

The world’s biggest climate fund wants to grow

 
Chloé Farand
Chloé Farand
 
Mia Mottley addresses the U.N. General Assembly. REUTERS/Mike Segar

THE NEWS

Scale up and speed up: That’s the motto for reshaping the global financial architecture to deliver the funds developing economies need to transition. Few organizations symbolize this more right now than the U.N.’s flagship climate fund.

Mafalda Duarte, Executive Director of the Green Climate Fund, recently unveiled a vision to triple its capitalization to $50 billion by 2030, while promising reforms and partnerships with multilateral development banks and private actors to get more dollars to carbon-cutting and adaptation projects in vulnerable countries.

Her ambition comes amid growing discussions over whether the existing international financial system is sufficiently able to respond to the climate crisis. Critics variously call for reform — Barbados Prime Minister Mia Mottley’s blueprint to refashion finance is gaining traction — or replacement: Countries like Kenya and the UAE are setting their sights on creating entirely new institutions to channel the funding needed to green economies.

“There is movement. The question is can we get that movement to be bigger and faster,” said Rachel Kyte, dean of the Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy at Tufts University.

CHLOÉ’S VIEW

Developing countries need cheap, long-term, and easily accessible financing to decarbonize and develop their economies. Duarte gets it. But her efforts, and those of the GCF, won’t be enough on their own — not by a long shot.

The GCF is the world’s largest dedicated climate fund, a pillar of the grand bargain between rich and poorer nations which underpins the 2015 Paris Agreement: Developing countries agreed to cut emissions in exchange for financial support from their wealthier peers. The replenishment of the GCF is critical for vulnerable nations to access affordable funding for climate investments, and Duarte is seeking fresh contributions at a pledging conference next week.

On its own, however, the GCF is too small to move the needle. Duarte acknowledged last week in remarks to the U.N. that even $50 billion was “a drop in the bucket” when compared to the additional climate finance needs of developing and emerging economies other than China, estimated at around $1.8 trillion a year by 2030.

But the GCF stands out for its ability to focus on the most vulnerable, and take more risks than most investors because it doesn’t have to worry about credit ratings. To scale financial flows, the GCF will “double down on mobilizing domestic private capital,” Duarte told CSIS, a Washington-based think-tank, on Monday.

Yet still more is required, and Duarte’s is one of multiple efforts aiming to bolster funding for developing nations. The Bridgetown Agenda — a blueprint for reforming the financial system championed by Mottley — is the most advanced diplomatic initiative responding to that scaling challenge. It calls on multilateral development banks to triple their lending from $100 billion a year currently to $300 billion, urges the banks’ shareholders to increase their capitalization, and demands developed countries rechannel about $130 billion of International Monetary Fund financing as additional lending for vulnerable nations.

A group of countries recently agreed to increase multilateral development bank lending by an extra $20 billion annually by optimizing the banks’ balance sheets. But Mottley warned leaders last week the ambition shouldn’t be below $100 billion. An influential recent report for the G20 concluded that the MDBs could increase their lending by “several hundreds of billions of dollars over the medium term” if they followed a series of recommendations, including on risk tolerance.

The issue is poised to be a major talking point at World Bank and International Monetary Fund meetings next month in Marrakech, where Barbados and its allies will “push for higher numbers,” Avinash Persaud, Mottley’s special envoy on investments, told me.

Other efforts are underway, too. There are calls on multilateral development banks to loosen their insistence on maintaining AAA ratings and increase lending; momentum is building behind debt-for-climate swaps, which can free up capital for heavily indebted nations; while the World Bank is increasing its lending capacity by loosening its equity-to-lending ratio to take on a bit more risk.

Developing countries’ climate and development finance needs are acute and growing. But ideas for financing mitigation and adaptation efforts are on the table. The question remains whether they can be seriously implemented.

Read more on why not everyone is convinced that simply reforming the financial system is enough. →

PostEmail
4

Fossil finance

The amount European banks have helped fossil fuel companies raise from global bond markets since 2016, according to a pan-European investigation published in The Guardian. The analysis of 1,700 bond issues found that some of Europe’s biggest lenders, including Deutsche Bank, HSBC, and Barclays, profited from the expansion of oil, gas, and coal by supporting the sale of fossil-fuel bonds, which have become the industry’s principal source of financing.

PostEmail
5

One Good Text

Ronak Gopaldas is a director at Signal Risk.

PostEmail
6

Indonesia opens carbon market

Trading began on Indonesia’s first carbon credit market on Tuesday, in a bid to speed up emission cuts from the country’s coal-dominated power sector and reach net zero by 2060. The Indonesia Carbon Exchange, or IDX Carbon, operated by the country’s main stock exchange, opened with nearly 460,000 tonnes of carbon being traded at prices starting at $4.50 a unit — far below prices on the European market. At the launch event, President Joko Widodo said carbon trading combined with other emission reduction efforts could deliver $194 billion in economic gains.

PostEmail
7

Lured by Latam

 
Jeronimo Gonzalez
Jeronimo Gonzalez
 

Chevron will ramp up oil output in Venezuela as it seeks to recoup $3 billion in unpaid debt from Caracas. In exchange for easing sanctions on Venezuela’s beleaguered oil industry, the U.S. is seeking a commitment from Caracas for free and fair presidential elections next year. Venezuelan President Nicolás Maduro, keen to revive his country’s devastated economy ahead of the vote, has also courted China. During a state visit to Beijing last month, Maduro said Venezuela and China would build a partnership “where energy and oil are at the axis.”

INSIGHTS

  • Chevron’s investment in Venezuela is part of a recent surge of interest in Latin America’s oil and gas sector. Saudi Aramco, for example, announced this month that it would acquire Chilean fuel distributor Esmax. The move marks the first investment by Aramco in the region, and is part of a wider push to expand its refining and chemicals operations worldwide.
  • Western oil majors have also ramped up their presence in the region in recent months. ExxonMobil has committed billions of dollars in investment to tap into the estimated 11 billion barrels of oil off Guyana’s coast, and TotalEnergies is leading oil and gas exploration in neighboring Suriname. Initial appraisals suggest Suriname holds 6.5 billion barrels of oil. Finally, Equinor last week requested approval for a $9 billion natural gas project off Brazil’s coast.
  • Despite having enormous renewable energy potential, Latin American countries have maintained their focus on exploiting their fossil-fuel deposits. Brazil is likely to approve a Petrobras oil exploration project near the mouth of the Amazon, while Mexico has committed tens of billions of dollars to an oil refinery that has ballooned in cost multiple times. Bucking the trend, Ecuadorian activists celebrated the cancellation of an oil project in the Yasuni National Park this year. But if Latin America’s economies continue to struggle, “sooner or later that oil is going to be exploited,” the head of an Amazon non-profit said.
PostEmail
8

China’s power play

 
Prashant Rao
Prashant Rao
 

When it comes to the energy transition, China is both hero and villain: A mammoth supplier of renewable energy, and overwhelmingly the world’s biggest coal-fired power generator. Beijing recently unveiled reforms that could strengthen the former reputation, and undermine the latter.

Last week, officials outlined an overhaul of how electricity is traded in China, building towards the creation of a national spot-trading market, a shift that experts say could sharply accelerate the country’s transition to renewable energy. Whereas most countries start with a “spot” market — where power is traded on a near-real time basis — and build up a medium-to-long-term trading regime, China has in effect done the opposite: Since 2017, it has been trialing spot trading, largely within provinces. The reformed system would see the creation of a national spot-trading market in 2025.

“This is a major undertaking, and a huge step forward for power market liberalisation in China,” analysts at The Lantau Group, a research firm focusing on China’s power sector, wrote. “It will also have important knock-on effects for China’s long-term decarbonisation efforts.”

Why is this good for renewables? A spot market, in theory, is better suited to solar and wind power’s volatility and unpredictability, more accurately reflecting supply and demand than a longer-term system where contracts are agreed far in advance. It also incentivizes companies to enter the market if they see short-term opportunities — like battery-storage firms looking to sop up solar power when prices hit rock bottom on sunny afternoons to sell them back to the grid later in the evening. Nationwide power trading also allows producers in one end of the country to supply consumers far away, meaning individual provinces do not need to keep huge amounts of spare capacity, typically in the form of coal, available for high-demand periods.

The system is not entirely perfect, of course: Renewable power generation tends to be concentrated, with huge solar arrays or wind farms in relatively small areas, meaning they will all produce for the grid at about the same time. That would send prices careening lower, possibly even into negative territory — as happened in Shandong province at various points on 176 days in 2022, according to China Dialogue, an outlet focused on the country’s environment — disincentivizing investment in renewables.

PostEmail