• D.C.
  • BXL
  • Lagos
  • Riyadh
  • Beijing
  • SG
  • D.C.
  • BXL
  • Lagos
Semafor Logo
  • Riyadh
  • Beijing
  • SG


Inside Tom Cotton’s unconventional push for Tulsi Gabbard

Feb 4, 2025, 7:12pm EST
politics
Sen. Tom Cotton and Tulsi Gabbard
Nathan Howard/Reuters
PostEmailWhatsapp

In this article:

Title icon

The News

Tom Cotton’s plan to get Tulsi Gabbard through the Senate Intelligence Committee was unconventional — Kyrsten Sinema even got involved.

The former Arizona independent senator offered to vouch for Gabbard, a close friend from their time in the House (Cotton served with them, too). Sinema ended up speaking to two former colleagues, Todd Young of Indiana and Susan Collins of Maine, about their concerns with Gabbard’s background, according to people familiar with the conversations.

Young and Collins this week supported Gabbard, allowing Cotton’s Senate Intelligence Committee to approve her once-embattled nomination to become Donald Trump’s director of national intelligence. She’s now on the cusp of confirmation, despite skepticism in the Washington establishment about her past meeting with the deposed leader of Syria and her past openness to the rhetoric of Vladimir Putin’s Russia.

Cotton, himself a hawk on Syria and Russia, mounted a surprising behind-the-scenes push to get Gabbard, a former liberal Democrat, through his closely divided committee. He had some help in the form of his own growing power: As of this year he’s now both the chair of the Senate Republican Conference, the No. 3 leadership job, and Intelligence chair.

AD

Though it’s not surprising that Cotton would support Trump’s nominees, Gabbard was a unique challenge for his committee. Gabbard and Cotton aren’t historically simpatico on national security, and she’d been dubious of some of the very programs the intelligence community uses to collect information.

“She’s a patriot, and she is dedicated to serving our country. We have certainly had our differences on this or that issue, but I also know that she’s committed to the badly needed reforms that I’ve championed,” Cotton told Semafor on Tuesday. “I welcome a partnership to try to pursue those reforms once she’s confirmed.”

Cotton worked hand in glove with Gabbard’s team of sherpas, the White House and Vice President JD Vance to aid Gabbard, who was in jeopardy just a couple weeks ago. Just before her hearing, Cotton convened a meeting with Sens. Joni Ernst of Iowa, Mike Rounds of South Dakota and former Senate Intelligence Chair Richard Burr to prepare Gabbard for her questioning.

AD

Still, the work wasn’t yet done after the hearing. Some Republicans did not like her answers to questions about classified information leaker Edward Snowden during her open hearing, but one of Cotton’s GOP colleagues noted her answer was far stronger behind closed doors.

Cotton advised Gabbard’s allies to get that answer into print before the vote.

On Sunday evening, a Gabbard op-ed ran in Newsweek that explained why she didn’t call Snowden a traitor after being criticized by lawmakers in both parties for her relative warmth toward Russia and her past visit to Syria.

She said in the piece that “Snowden should have raised his concerns about illegal surveillance through authorized channels” and offered a plan to prevent “Snowden-like” leaks.

AD

In this article:

Title icon

Know More

In a conversation late last year, Trump asked Cotton whether he would be able to get Gabbard out of his committee. Despite the myriad challenges ahead, Cotton answered in the affirmative.

Cotton met one by one with all the GOP members of his committee to hear out their concerns. In addition to Sinema, former Trump national security adviser Robert O’Brien talked to senators about Gabbard. And Trump himself spoke to Young about her, Young said on Tuesday.

“i know there’s been enormous pressure put on members,” said Sen. Mark Warner, D-Va., his party’s top member on the committee.

Cotton says he told backers of Gabbard to give Intelligence Committee members space to make their own decisions. Republicans were flooded with vitriol from Trump supporters for their initial reluctance to immediately back Pete Hegseth’s bid to lead the Pentagon, but Cotton said in the interview that he “discouraged any interested party working on Tulsi’s behalf from exerting any pressure.”

“Senators deserve the time and the space needed to carefully and deliberately consider Tulsi nomination, and, for that matter, any nomination or any piece of legislation,” Cotton said. “And the best way to win votes in the Senate is always to work in a collegial collaborative fashion, providing the information and analysis needed to persuade your colleagues.”

Still, Elon Musk couldn’t quite help himself. He called Young out as a “deep state puppet” over the weekend, then offered a mea culpa after speaking with the Indiana senator.

Less than 48 hours before Young endorsed Gabbard, Musk called him “a great ally in restoring power to the people from the vast, unelected bureaucracy.”

Title icon

Notable

  • Robert F. Kennedy Jr. convinced Bill Cassidy to support him by offering him input on HHS staffing, Politico reports.
  • Young faced challenges on the nomination that the IndyStar looked at.
AD
AD