• D.C.
  • BXL
  • Lagos
  • Dubai
  • Beijing
  • SG
rotating globe
  • D.C.
  • BXL
  • Lagos
Semafor Logo
  • Dubai
  • Beijing
  • SG


In this newsletter, Max has a run of scoops — including a big one on how Carlson’s firing was intert͏‌  ͏‌  ͏‌  ͏‌  ͏‌  ͏‌ 
 
cloudy Kyiv
cloudy Washington
thunderstorms Los Angeles
rotating globe
May 1, 2023
semafor

Media

Media
Sign up for our free newsletters
 
Ben Smith
Ben Smith

Welcome to Semafor Media, where we break the news behind the news.

I’ve spent my career in digital media, so it was humbling to stand in a corner at the lavish CBS News party at the French Ambassador’s residence Saturday night, talking about the collapse of BuzzFeed News, which I used to lead, and Vice News.

Legacy media is hardly out of the woods. But these institutions have proven more formidable than the revolutionaries of the last decade would have had it. The talk in Washington was mostly of the other corporate media flex — the firing of Tucker Carlson by Rupert Murdoch. Meanwhile off in sports media, the NBAs Phoenix Suns and WNBA’s Phoenix Mercury are ditching cable and headed back to local broadcast — plus streaming. That hybrid, more than anything, may be a glimpse at the future. The Correspondents Dinner itself, which had seemed like a dying institution, has settled back into a happy Biden-era groove.

Speaking of the enduring power of legacy media (and apologies for the self-promotional pirouette): I was unduly thrilled this morning by a great New York Times review of my new book Traffic: Genius, Rivalry, and Delusion in the Billion-Dollar Race to Go Viral. The Times called it “engrossing and suspenseful” and that the book’s “moral seriousness …lifts “Traffic” above other accounts of adventures in start-up land.”

The book is the origin story of this media moment, and you can (please!) buy a copy here!

In this newsletter, Max has a run of scoops — including a big one on how Carlson’s firing was intertwined with the American politics of Ukraine. In lower-stakes drama, Kellyanne Conway and Molly Jong-Fast are disputing what happened between them at a DC party, Dominion is denying the latest theory on Carlson’s firing, and ABC News apparently wasn’t paying the closest attention to its 538 acquisition.

Box Score

Washington: Biden and the media exceeded each other’s low expectations at the White House Correspondents’ Dinner and did one more thing of value: Keeping captive Wall Street Journal reporter Evan Gershkovich at the top of the agenda. — CNN

New York: The Wall Street Journal’s editorial page has turned into a rapid-response operation for the Roberts Supreme Court, lashing out at uncontested reporting in ProPublica, Politico, and at anyone else who covers the justices. — WSJ

Los Angeles: “Just as streaming has fundamentally changed how we watch TV, it’s also altered the way TV is made — and how everyone gets paid.” Now writers are about to strike for a new deal. Bloomberg

PostEmail
Max Tani & Morgan Chalfant

The Murdochs’ Ukraine connection

Ukrainian Presidential Press Service/Handout via REUTERS

THE SCOOP

Fox News Executive Chairman Rupert Murdoch held a previously unreported call with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy this spring in which the two discussed the war and the anniversary of the deaths of Fox News journalists last March. The Ukrainian president had a similar conversation with Lachlan Murdoch on March 15, which Zelenskyy noted in a little-noticed aside during a national broadcast last month.

The conversations came weeks before the Murdochs fired their biggest star and most outspoken critic of American support for Ukraine, Tucker Carlson. Senior Ukrainian officials had made their objections to Carlson’s coverage known to Fox executives, but Zelenskyy did not raise it on the calls with the Murdochs, according to one person familiar with the details of the calls.

MAX’S VIEW

The Murdoch’s have not revealed which of Carlson’s many provocations triggered his firing, and there’s no particular suggestion that Zelenskyy — whom Carlson had called a “dictator” — delivered the final blow.

But Carlson’s firing will immediately relieve pressure on key Capitol Hill Ukraine supporters whom Carlson had criticized on air — and sometimes pressed behind the scenes to change their positions on the war.

Texas Rep. Michael McCaul has been one of the most outspoken Republican supporters of the US support for Ukraine, stepping out of line to occasionally reprimand figures in his own party who do not share his views on the subject.

In a segment last year, the Fox News host told viewers that the Republican chairman of the House Foreign Affairs Committee had privately called his show “Russian disinformation.”

“In other words, not only are we wrong — which is fine — we are disloyal Americans. We’re doing the bidding of a foreign power,” Carlson said. “That is not fine, that is slander.”

According to two people familiar with the conversation, the then-Fox News host also made his displeasure to McCaul known in a tense private conversation in which Carlson criticized the congressman’s comments, describing the congressman as having a low IQ. (Both Carlson and McCaul’s office declined to discuss the conversation).

The populist Republican right remains hostile to the war effort and at times openly sympathetic to Russia. But none of Fox’s other top figures seem to share Carlson’s zeal.

“Clearly, he spooked a lot of members into not being fully supportive of Ukraine,” a senior Republican congressional aide told Semafor. Carlson’s ouster, the aide added, “probably reduces the loudest voice out there against U.S. support.”

Regardless of the reason for Carlson’s departure, more moderate pro-Ukraine members of the Republican caucus on the Hill are not hiding their relief.

“There have been some that have argued that he was setting foreign policy for the Republican Party, which I find to be bizarre. Certainly not for me,” Sen. Mitt Romney told the Hill. “To the primary [Republican] voter, the active participant, the grassroot voter, he’s a person they listen to and has a big influence.”

ROOM FOR DISAGREEMENT

Washington has a long history of pushing out dissenting voices on issues of war and peace. “Cable news may struggle to find an entertainer equally skilled at skewering comfortable pieties on the left and right,” Lee Harris and Luke Goldstein wrote in the progressive American Prospect, before being drubbed by their colleagues for ignoring Carlson’s appeal to racists.

THE VIEW FROM MOSCOW

Russia state media outlets have offered the outgoing host a job on their networks: RT tweeted that he could “question more” by joining the network, while Russia’s most popular broadcaster said he would “happily offer you a job if you wish to carry on as a presenter and host! You are always welcome in Russia and Moscow, we wish you the best of luck.”

PostEmail
One Good Text

PostEmail
Intel
Fox News

Bemused Tucker Face: It’s incredible that none of us has yet quite nailed the reason for Tucker Carlson’s departure from Fox News. Among the candidates: Misogynistic emails, insubordination, alleged racist emails, thinking he was bigger than the Murdochs, the Grossberg lawsuit, Ukraine, vaccines, and more.

Here’s another: Some sympathetic to the ousted host have suggested that Carlson’s ouster was a secret codicil to Fox’s massive settlement with Dominion earlier this month. Stephanie Walstrom, a spokesperson for the voting machine company, flatly denied that suggestion: “This isn’t true,” she said when asked about the rumor by Semafor.

Resist: Passing for drama over White House Correspondents weekend was a confrontation between the former Trump aide Kellyanne Conway and liberal opinion writer Molly Jong-Fast, who is friends with Conway’s ex-husband George. Jong Fast told Semafor that Conway called her “a mess” when the two crossed paths at the Washington Hilton, and made other critical comments about her within earshot at Tammy Haddad’s brunch on Saturday morning. Conway said she’d never had a conversation with Jong Fast. By early Sunday, a more lurid version spun by Jong Fast’s friends and other media gossips had spread widely.

Data breach: ABC News is scrambling to find a replacement for Nate Silver’s election forecasting model, which the 538 founder is taking with him when he leaves the news organization at the end of his contract. According to two sources with knowledge of the situation, ABC executives were slow to realize that the company only owned some of the models that 538 used to forecast major elections, and that many were on rent from Silver as part of the initial deal to bring the data journalism site to ESPN ten years ago.

“They have put very very very little bandwidth into managing 538, and they seem pretty clueless about who-owns-what IP questions,” one person familiar told Semafor.

PostEmail
Evidence
PostEmail
How Are We Doing?

Are you enjoying Semafor Media? The more people read us, the better we’ll get. So please share it with your family, friends and colleagues.

But we can’t deliver media news and insights from inside your spam folder.  Be sure to add ben.smith@semafor.com to your contacts.  In Gmail, drag this newsletter over to your ‘Primary’ tab. And, of course, you can always reach me with tips, ideas, criticisms and insults by replying to these emails.

Thanks for reading!

Want more Semafor?  Explore all our newsletters at semafor.com/newsletters.

— Ben

PostEmail