• D.C.
  • BXL
  • Lagos
  • Dubai
  • Beijing
  • SG
rotating globe
  • D.C.
  • BXL
  • Lagos
Semafor Logo
  • Dubai
  • Beijing
  • SG


They still find an audience in Russia through telegram and YouTube.͏‌  ͏‌  ͏‌  ͏‌  ͏‌  ͏‌ 
 
sunny Riga
sunny London
thunderstorms New York
rotating globe
July 10, 2023
semafor

Media

Media
Sign up for our free newsletters
 
Ben Smith
Ben Smith

Welcome to Semafor Media, which will still be here for you when you’re sick of Threads.

Max broke the story Thursday of Elon Musk’s threat to sue Mark Zuckerberg over Threads, a sign that this “Twitter-killer” may do just that. The drama is a reminder that social networks aren’t as stable as they look — they’re social, more like bars and clubs than physical infrastructure.

As for me, I was on my annual trip to see family in Riga, Latvia. Regular readers may recall occasional inexplicable Riga bylines through the years, but the city has become an unlikely media hub, as the center of Russian journalism in exile from the Ukraine war. I wrote below about the complexities of that exile.

Also today: An ugly fight inside ABC, a hot labor news outlet, Boris Johnson’s podcast pitch, and a text from Jake Tapper.

It was a scoopy week at Semafor, including also Morgan Chalfant’s revelation that the FBI has joined the high-stakes inquiry into Biden’s Iran envoy. You can read her work in Principals, available with one click here.

Box Score
Vuk Valcic/SOPA Images/LightRocket via Getty Images

London: Every journalist in town (and I!) are pretty sure we know which prominent BBC host has been suspended for paying a teen for “sexual pictures,” but tight UK libel restrictions mean none of us will print the name! — The Sun

Moscow: Telegram has defied Western norms about content moderation — which turns out to be handy when it’s the Russian government seeking to censor it. — The Verge

Paris: Le Monde and other French outlets have found their way onto Threads, even though it’s not technically available in the European Union. — Bloomberg

PostEmail
Ben Smith

Russian journalists settle into exile

Daria Kalashnikova / Media Hub Riga

THE NEWS

RIGA — Here are some of the things Russian journalists living in exile here in the Latvian capital know they can’t do:

They can’t go home. They can’t get Ukrainian visas to report from the front of the war. They can’t easily take payment from subscribers in Russia, due to sanctions. The stringers who send them videos from inside Russia can’t show their faces, which is a killer for TikTok. And most of all they can’t express self-pity — nobody wants to hear it from Russians.

“It’s a pretty interesting experience during the war time,” Latvia’s new president, Edgars Rinkēvičs, who had been instrumental in issuing hundreds of visas to Russian journalists as foreign minister but has been publicly cool to the journalists, said in an interview last week. “Emotions are running high in Latvian society after seeing many atrocities committed by the Russian troops in Ukraine.”

Outlets from the Russian services of the BBC, Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, and Deutsche Welle to key Russian voices TV Rain and a European edition of Novaya Gazeta moved here to join the online outlet Meduza, which has been based in Latvia for nearly a decade.

But a turning point came in December, when a presenter on the highest profile of them, TV Rain, suggested viewers send help to Russian conscripts on the front. The station apologized and fired him in the face of a backlash from its viewers, but a right-leaning Latvian regulator stripped the station’s license, calling it a threat to national security. A court upheld that ruling last week.

“What would be just a minor issue five years ago or three years ago, is considered completely different,” Rinkēvičs said, calling the ruling “correct.”

KNOW MORE

The exiled Russian outlets publish into Russia’s strangely porous media ecosystem, where some websites are blocked but millions still follow independent media through Telegram and, for now, YouTube.

And cooling Latvian postures toward the Russian journalists infuriates their allies, including Sabine Sile, the creator of Media Hub Riga, where many of them work.

“If Putin hates them so much, that means that what they do works against him,” she said. “It’s not in our interest to have another North Korea.”

I got to Riga expecting the beginnings of an exodus. And in fact, TV Rain, whose travails were at the center of a recent, powerfully gloomy piece by the New Yorker’s Masha Gessen, was working on shipping its studio set to Amsterdam.

But TV Rain, so far, is an outlier. Many other Russian journalists say they plan to stay, and the international organizations are settling in. Riga seems likely to remain what it has ambivalently become: a key hub for telling one of the most important stories in the world.

“Russian media is one of the most successful parts of what remains of Russian society,” said Kirill Martynov, the editor in chief of Novaya Gazeta Evropa, whose former colleagues faced a brutal attack in Chechnya last week.

BEN’S VIEW

The new mission for a journalistic community that reported heroically through the closing aperture is captured in a new book by a former TV Rain star, Mikhail Zygar. “War and Punishment” is a kind of “People’s History of the United States” or 1619 Project but aimed at curing the “disease” of “nationalist history,” of Russian nationalism, rather than gauzy American historiography.

The outlets in Riga are settling into this strange new world with a range of resignation and optimism. They were invaluable sources for reading the tea leaves of the Prigozhin mutiny, sharing videos on Telegram and conducting man-on-the-street interviews from Rostov-on-Don.

But the long-term prospects are unclear. The Russian government has experimented with escalating blocks of the internet, and journalists are split on whether their ability to reach into Moscow through Telegram, YouTube, and even Gmail might narrow as the government pushes users toward local services like Yandex and Vkontakte. The trend toward the national control of the internet can be felt from Latvia to the United States, where legislators have sought to ban TikTok and pornography; Russia has the tight Chinese censorship as a model.

Meanwhile, even more bylines have started turning up in the English-language press, from Milana Mazaeva in the New York Times to the FT’s Anastasia Stognei.

Others, though, are settling in for the long haul. Martynov has been reading up the Russian media in exile after the Bolshevik revolution. The most important outlet, Segodnya, was published in Riga from 1919 until the Soviets took the country over in 1940.

He likes to quote a modified version of a favorite line from Russian novelist Ivan Turgenev: “‘In days of doubt, in days of dreary musings on our country’s fate, thou alone art my stay and support, mighty, true, free Russian language Riga Airport.’

For The View From TV Rain, read here.

PostEmail
Plug

A Media Operator is part of our newsletter swaps program.

Jacob Donnelly’s A Media Operator is on my shortlist of vital media biz publications.

Jacob, a pragmatist and the publisher at Morning Brew, is writing for media operators and executives looking to build sustainable publications. His newsletter comes out twice weekly and brings together a community of readers paying close attention to quickly evolving tactics and trends in the digital media industry.

Subscribe to A Media Operator here.

PostEmail
One Good Text

CNN Anchor and Chief Washington Correspondent Jake Tapper is the host of The Lead with Jake Tapper and the author of the new novel All The Demons Are Here: A Thriller.

PostEmail
Exclusive Intel
Jonathan Torgovnik/Getty Images

Sporting News: The Times’s long-suffering sports desk, known for big splashes but always struggling for a core audience, is bracing to be folded into the also-struggling Athletic. Some of its reporters will likely be offered jobs in other sections of the paper. The Washington Post has the plaintive letter from reporters “twisting in the wind,” and Semafor is told that the Times has announced a meeting tomorrow with sports staff.

Morning Show, Episode 10,000: A messy feud is brewing at ABC News’ flagship show between its respected top producer and disgruntled on-air talent. Two network insiders told Semafor that the company was investigating complaints that Good Morning America and its executive producer Simone Swink had not done enough to elevate black on-air correspondents on the morning show. Others at the network have been skeptical of these complaints, pointing out that GMA is hosted by two of the most prominent black journalists in television news, and noting that Swink herself elevated nonwhite correspondents to host roles on GMA’s weekend counterpart.

Solidarity Forever: The pro-labor, advocacy news organization More Perfect Union is by some measures the fastest-growing new news organization around. The outlet, which is led by former HuffPost executive editor Nico Pitney and picked up some staff from NowThisNews, aims to elevate the voices of workers and often focuses on organizing fights like Starbucks and Amazon.

The organization has 220 million video views across social platforms. A spokesman sent over a fact sheet comparing it particularly favorably to Courier Newsroom, a network of local sites set up to help Democratic campaigns.

One twist: More Perfect Union has rallied its audience against Microsoft’s purchase of Activision — even though the union that is trying to organize gaming workers, Communications Workers of America, supports the merger.

Long Way from the Podium: Former White House Correspondents Association president Ed Henry was arrested last month under the suspicion of driving under the influence. Henry, who is now with the right-wing streaming news service Real America’s Voice, was pulled over last month after police observed him driving erratically with a flat tire in Palm Beach, Florida. Henry’s attorney told Semafor that the anchor “respectfully provided a sample of his breath that was below a .08, and thus below the legal limit in Florida.” Henry has not yet been charged.

— Max

Audite!: Boris Johnson is getting back into media. The former prime minister, who recently joined the Daily Mail as a columnist, has been pitching a new podcast on the classics ….

PostEmail
Hot on Semafor
  • Twitter is threatening to sue Meta over Threads, Max Tani scooped.
  • Battles against mask and vaccine mandates made Ron DeSantis a Republican star. But he’s losing ground in the presidential race as America moves on from COVID.
  • Why causal AI might be the next frontier in artificial intelligence.
  • Semafor Africa has a modest proposal for peace in the Jollof Wars.
PostEmail